Because the airway is already narrow before anything is given. Brachycephalic anaesthesia is the same procedure done on an animal with less margin, and the 2020 AAHA anaesthesia and monitoring guidelines say it plainly, that brachycephalic dogs and cats are more prone to upper airway obstruction and have been shown to have higher airway-related anaesthetic complication rates compared with nonbrachycephalic breeds.
That is a reason to plan differently, not to cancel. We are open 8 AM to 12 AM every day and the phone is answered 24 hours on 055 620 4085.
What is a brachycephalic dog or cat?
One bred with a shortened muzzle. Cornell’s Riney Canine Health Center defines it as a dog whose skull bones are compressed so that it has a more flattened or pushed-in facial conformation compared with other dogs, and names the breeds it sees most often.
- English bulldog, pug, French bulldog and Boston terrier, which Cornell lists as the most frequently affected.
- Boxer, Pekingese, shih tzu, Chinese shar pei, Lhasa apso and bull mastiff, which Cornell lists as also affected.
- Persians among cats, which International Cat Care says are bred to have a relatively flat-faced appearance.
The problem is not the short nose itself. Cornell explains that the anatomical variations of the skull bones result in abnormalities of the upper respiratory system, with varying degrees of breathing difficulty depending on the extent of those abnormalities, and that the severity of symptoms may increase as the dog ages.
Why does a short face change the risk?
Because the airway narrows further the moment the animal relaxes. Cornell lists four findings that obstruct airflow in these breeds, and AAHA’s point about airway control is why each of them matters more once the animal is anaesthetised.
- Stenotic nares, which Cornell describes as congenitally small nostrils that may also collapse as the dog inhales.
- An elongated soft palate, which Cornell says can cause obstruction of airflow into the larynx.
- Everted laryngeal saccules, tissue near the vocal cords that Cornell says is pulled inward during inhalation and can block airflow.
- A hypoplastic trachea, a windpipe Cornell describes as proportionally too narrow, and one with no surgical correction.
Cornell also notes that over time the condition worsens as a result of the dog working harder to breathe, because tissues in the throat become swollen or inflamed and obstruct the flow of air further. In our view an animal who has been compensating for years has less reserve on the day of the procedure.
The numbers behind this are not small. The Royal Veterinary College’s VetCompass study of 4,308 pugs found brachycephalic obstructive airway syndrome to be the disorder with the highest risk in the breed, with pugs almost 54 times more likely to have the condition, and its study of 2,781 French bulldogs found narrowed nostrils to be that breed’s highest risk, more than 42 times more likely than in other dogs.
Read also: Cherry eye in bulldogs and shih tzus
How risky is anaesthesia for a dog?
Lower than it feels in a consulting room, and the published figures are worth hearing before you decide. AAHA says that in healthy dogs and cats the risks of anaesthetic-related death were estimated at 0.05 percent, or one in 1,849, in dogs and 0.11 percent, or one in 895, in cats.
The timing in that same sentence is the part that changes how a clinic works. AAHA says death most frequently occurs in the first three hours after the operation, which is why it also says monitoring of the recovering patient should be maintained with the same vigilance as during the maintenance phase of anaesthesia.
Health status matters more than breed alone. AAHA’s preanaesthesia guidance scores patients from one to five on the American Society of Anesthesiologists scale, and reports that an increase in that status from one or two to three, or from three to four or five, increased the odds of anaesthesia-related death in dogs and cats.
So a healthy flat-faced dog is not the same patient as a flat-faced dog who is overweight and already struggling in the heat, which is why brachycephalic anaesthesia starts with the examination rather than with the breed.
How is brachycephalic anaesthesia planned?
Brachycephalic anaesthesia changes the plan at both ends, before induction and through recovery. The steps below are ours, drawn from what AAHA sets out as the preanaesthesia and recovery standard rather than from a brachycephalic protocol of its own.
- A face mask is used for preoxygenation before induction, which AAHA lists among the airway equipment that should be ready.
- An intravenous catheter goes in, which AAHA says should be left in place until the patient is extubated and in sternal recumbency with parameters back to normal.
- Anything correctable is corrected first, and AAHA’s list includes anxiety, pain, dehydration, anaemia and electrolyte problems.
- A dedicated anaesthetist watches the animal, which AAHA describes as patient-specific monitoring performed by somebody in that role.
- The breathing tube stays in longer than it would in another breed, and AAHA says to extubate only when breathing rate and oxygen saturation are within normal limits and the animal can protect its airway by vigorously swallowing.
- Somebody stays with the animal until it is alert, warm and able to walk, which AAHA names as the end point for close observation.
The gut gets its own attention in brachycephalic anaesthesia. Cornell lists hiatal hernia and gastro-oesophageal reflux among the conditions associated with the syndrome, along with aspiration pneumonia, and a 2022 review of the condition reports that medical therapy aimed at those oesophageal and gastrointestinal problems has been shown to decrease the risk of complications after surgery. In practice that means the vet may give something for nausea and acid, and sets the fasting time for the individual animal rather than by a single rule.
Timing of the procedure itself is a lever too. AAHA reports that increased anaesthetic risk has been documented for procedures occurring late in the day or after normal hours, because of inadequate time for stabilisation, limited staff availability and staff fatigue, and says non-emergency procedures may be best performed during the next available regular clinic day. A flat-faced dog booked for neutering goes early in our list for that reason.
Are flat-faced cats affected the same way?
Yes, and the AAHA sentence on brachycephalic anaesthesia covers cats as well as dogs, since it says brachycephalic dogs and cats are more prone to upper airway obstruction. In these cats the day-to-day signs get accepted as normal for the breed, which is what we see, so the first clue arrives late.
Breed data exists for cats too. The Royal Veterinary College’s VetCompass study of Persians reports that almost two thirds of Persian cats suffer from at least one health condition, and says the high levels of dental and eye problems seen in Persians are thought to result from the brachycephalic, commonly referred to as flat-faced, shape of these cats’ heads.
International Cat Care puts the cause plainly, saying the Persian is bred to have a relatively flat-faced appearance which, when severe, can lead to multiple health problems. Two of the problems it lists on the same page change an anaesthetic rather than a coat, which are polycystic kidney disease, found in more than a third of all Persian and Exotic Shorthaired cats in the 1990s, and heart disease in the form of a thickened heart muscle.
Neither shows from the outside. Our own rule is that a murmur heard on the morning of surgery is a reason to pause and investigate rather than to press on, which our page on a heart murmur in puppies explains, and older Persians get their kidney values checked first.
For an owner the practical point is that a Persian coming in for dental work, a groom under sedation or a spay gets the same airway plan a pug gets. Say the breed when you book, so brachycephalic anaesthesia is in the diary with the time it needs.
Does Dubai heat make the risk worse?
It adds a second problem on either side of brachycephalic anaesthesia, because a flat-faced animal cools itself badly. Cornell’s own conservative treatment list for these breeds includes minimising panting and avoiding excessive heat and humidity, which is a description of a Dubai summer.
MSD adds the mechanism. Writing about laryngeal disorders, MSD says brachycephalic and obese dogs develop laryngeal oedema and laryngitis through severe panting or respiratory effort during excitement or hyperthermia, so the swelling an animal arrives with can be worse than the swelling it normally lives with.
Our own handling of that is simple. The car is cooled before the animal goes into it, the carrier does not sit in the sun while you park, and the walk from the car to the door happens at the shaded end of the building. Those are our arrangements rather than anyone’s guideline, and they exist because an overheated flat-faced dog starts the appointment already behind.
Read also: Storing pet medication in Dubai heat
What should I ask before booking the surgery?
Five questions, and any clinic should answer all of them without hesitating. They come from the AAHA steps above rather than from anything we invented, so the answers are comparable between clinics.
- Who monitors my animal during the procedure, and is that their only job while it is happening.
- Will my dog be preoxygenated before induction, and will the tube stay in until she is swallowing properly.
- Is a pre-anaesthetic blood test being run in the clinic’s own laboratory, and what would change if it came back abnormal.
- Where does she recover, and who is with her for the first three hours after she wakes.
- What time of day is the procedure booked for, and can it move earlier.
Our answers are on the surgery page, with the fees for the consultation, the blood work and the procedure on the price list. You get a written estimate after the examination.
When should I call after the anaesthetic?
Call 055 620 4085 the same hour if the breathing at home is noisier than it was before the procedure. Cornell is explicit that this can become an emergency, saying that if your dog is experiencing a respiratory crisis, immediate transport to your veterinarian or nearest emergency hospital is essential.
After brachycephalic anaesthesia, blue or grey gums, collapse or laboured breathing mean coming in now rather than waiting for a call back. After midnight the clinic is closed and the nurse will tell you which hospital is open and nearest.
- Laboured breathing, or stretching the neck out to get air.
- Gums that look bluish rather than pink, which Cornell lists among the signs in these breeds.
- Open-mouth breathing in a cat, which is never normal at rest.
- Collapse, which Cornell also lists.
- Gagging when swallowing food or water, or a cough that was not there before.
- Repeated vomiting or bringing up fluid, especially with a new cough.
- Panting that does not settle within ten minutes in a cool room, which is our own threshold.
Keep her cool and calm, do not offer food or water, and come in, telling the nurse on the phone that the patient is flat-faced and had an anaesthetic today. Noisy breathing for a few hours after a breathing tube is common, but it should be improving by bedtime rather than getting louder. Our emergency page says what happens when you arrive.
Frequently asked questions
Short answers to what owners search for before booking brachycephalic anaesthesia.
Can a pug be safely anaesthetised?
Yes, with a plan built for the airway. AAHA’s published risk of anaesthetic-related death in healthy dogs is 0.05 percent, and its guidance is that tailoring each patient’s anaesthetic plan to their specific needs allows the team to provide optimum care. The breed changes the plan rather than the answer.
Is sedation safer than general anaesthesia?
Not automatically. AAHA says heavy sedation is not suitable for all patients and may actually increase the odds for anaesthesia-related death, and that general anaesthesia with airway control is required for any patient with airway compromise. For a flat-faced animal, control of the airway is the point.
At what age should BOAS surgery be done?
Earlier rather than later. Cornell says earlier intervention leads to better outcomes and that dogs operated on under two years of age do better, while dogs who have developed laryngeal collapse have less favourable outcomes with or without surgery. That work goes to a surgical specialist, and we arrange the referral.
Can a flat-faced dog live a normal life?
Many can. Cornell says dogs with milder cases of BOAS can have normal life expectancies and that dogs with milder or fewer defects have a better prognosis. Weight control, a harness instead of a neck collar and avoiding the heat are on Cornell’s own list of what helps.
Does my dog need a blood test before surgery?
For a flat-faced surgical patient we advise it. The 2019 AAHA canine life stage guidelines decline to make a recommendation on preanaesthetic bloodwork, but they say so for apparently healthy dogs, and a brachycephalic animal booked for airway surgery is not in that group. AAHA’s preanaesthesia list names anaemia, dehydration and electrolyte problems among the things to correct before anaesthesia, and a blood test is how those are found.